Apr
Immigration Debate
Posted in General | No Comments »Unless you live under a rock, you have heard about the revised Arizona statute concerning illegal immigration.
I believe knowledge is power. If you want to know what the statute says before you make judgments, click on the link below:
http://www.azleg.gov/legtext/49leg/2r/bills/sb1070s.pdf
After reading it myself, the hullabaloo seems to be about Part I, section B. It basically says that if a law officer suspects someone is an illegal alien, he can ask for documentation that proves citizenship.
Let me backtrack and just talk about illegal aliens first. The U.S. is the greatest nation on Earth. It is the Land of Opportunity. Why wouldn’t people from oppressive, poor, and/or violent nations want to come here.
Every year, people from all walks of life immigrate to this country. It is not an easy process to complete and can take a very long time. I have had quite a few friends from Canada who went through this process and it really was not simple. Thankfully, they stuck with it and were eventually rewarded with U.S. citizenship.
This process is a major problem. Since I’ve never personally gone through it, I will have to write hypothetically. If this process was streamlined, I believe more people who opt to move here legally. This is a situation where I believe interference from the federal government could improve the status quo. Of course, since immigration is a bureaucratic institution, there are mounds of red tape to burrow through. Reduce the red tape. Run background checks. This would require global cooperation, but may help squash the numbers of illegal immigrants.
What annoys me more than anything concerning this issue are all the name-callers out there. They call Arizonans “racists”, “Nazis”, etc., but don’t offer any solutions. I want to discuss each major accusation point-by-point.
Racists? I don’t think so. This isn’t about a person’s color or ethnicity. It’s about people coming to this country illegally and then securing jobs intended for it’s citizens. Illegals use emergency rooms which drive up medical costs and schools that use state funds to education their children. As a mother, I’m appalled that these children get special services, including ESL, all while taking away from my own children.
Racial Profiling? Absolutely. When I was seven months pregnant, I was pulled over at a security checkpoint. Did I look like a terrorist? I don’t think so. The truth is, MOST terrorists look a certain way. Most Mexican illegals look a certain way too. So, how can Immigration NOT racially profile. This “name” is simply ridiculous as far as I am concerned!
Nazis. If I was a Holocaust survivor or a relative of one, I would be appalled. AZ is not taking innocent people forcefully from their homes and leading them to their deaths. First, illegal immigrants are not innocent. They are guilty of being in this country without citizenship. Second, they are not being led to gas chambers and systemically murdered while the world watched. This “name” is a gross overstatement and those who have used it have degraded themselves to school yard bullies.
Is this law the right answer? Parts of it are. No one else is doing anything. AZ Senator McCain has been asking for reinforcement at the border for years, whether it is a fence, additional border control agents or National Guard. Violence has been spilling over the border for years. Our government DOES have a duty to protect it’s citizens.
One more point: the Constitution. I’ve heard some people say that illegals deserve protection under the Constitution. I DON’T THINK SO. You need to be a citizen for that!
I am glad that Governor Jan Brewer chose to DO something, since I personally like to be proactive. Now that AZ has the world’s attention, maybe we’ll find a great, instead of decent, answer to this question.
Oh, and to San Francisco and St. Paul, cities who have decided to boycott AZ - way to punish the people of the state in an effort to take a stance against it’s government. What a vindictive, petty thing to do. Should I call you racists now too?